Beyond Words / Volume Four 1982
by Rabbi Meir Kahane
Dear Mr. Begin,
On the day that Yamit, a city in Israel, was murdered, you informed your Cabinet that you had dispatched a letter of thanks to me. The letter was in response to my efforts to dissuade young Jews in a bunker in the Sinai from risking their lives. In your statement you added that we are not friends and never would be. I wish address myself to your letter, as a whole, and to the last comment, in particular.
Our Rabbis tell us (Sanhedrin 92b): “Why did Omri (king of Israel, who did that which was evil in the eyes of the L-rd) merit establishing his rule? Because he added one city (Shomron, in Samaria) to the Land of Israel.”
I wonder if you comprehend the profound meaning of those words, Menachem Begin, who was crowned by the crowds in the teeming slums and development towns, “Begin, king of Israel”? Consider the words carefully, for in them the Rabbis place all of the awesome meaning and love that is the essence of Jewish obligation to the holy land, the land of the G-d of Israel, Eretz Yisrael. In them is all the fervor and totality of love for the land of G-d and His chosen people. And in them, O king of Israel, is the silent but unmistakable converse the awful punishment, G-d forbid should one do the Opposite.
You say that we are not friends. That is true. But do you, did you ever, pause to consider why? Most importantly, did you ever think deeply into the question why I, as so many others who followed and admired you for the man you were and the thoughts you espoused and the deeds you did – have turned from you? For it is not I, alone, whom you cannot bear to listen to. There are so many others – and specifically, of the men and women who fought the same struggle that you did who broke with you who call you the names that you, so typically, call ‘blashemy,’ but whose true crime is the pain of awful guilt that they lay upon you? Have you ever considered why not only Meir Kahane but Geula Cohen and Yisrael Eldad-Scheib, who fought in the underground, and Shmuel Katz, who served under you on the staff of the Irgun Zvai Leumi, and a host of other soldiers in your ranks have turned on you and cried the same “blasphemy”?
If you do not or if you refuse to know, let me explain it Menachem, so that you will know why your rule is doomed to come to an end, and most important, so that you may yet find the courage to reverse the tragedy you have brought on our people and yourself, so that we may again be friends.
I remember a man named Begin, no, a legend. It was the year 5709, 1949 by the reckoning of the gentiles, I stood, a young member of the Jabotinsky youth movement, Betar, at attention in misdar, formation, at the then still elegant Diplomat Hotel in Manhattan. You had come to the United States for the first time, you who were for us a hero of the Jewish people. You who had given for Eretz Yisrael, you who helped to drive the gentile from the land of the Jews. You who symbolized for us the map that was part of Betar, both sides of the Jordan. You who sang with us the words of Jabotinsky, “Shte Gado laYarden — there are two sides to the Jordan, the one is ours and the other, too.” And of course it was not only the western boundaries that were declared inviolate, but every part of Eretz Yisrael. And, Menachem Begin, it is not the British occupiers who define the borders of our land; it is not a League of Nations that decrees where the holiness of the Chosen land rests. The borders of the land of the L-rd are set by Him and in the south the Divinity decrees, “from the river of Egypt., ” (Geness …15:18)
Menachem, the Jews who came to Yamit and the other settlements in the Sinai were Jews who understood that this was Divinely decreed to be part of the Land of Israel. Their faith and dedication were things that you once had, attributes and characteristics that are threatened by the attainment of power and honor. They who left their homes and employment, they who took their children out of school and brought them to live under conditions of absolute minimal comfort, they who left cities for the sands of Sinai – understood what a younger Menachem Begin had once grasped and that which he lost in his old age. The Begin who thundered against Ben-Gurion in 1956, when the Sinai was abandoned under gentile pressure, repeated the obscenity when he reached the seat of power. The Begin who cried out against a Labor government at the time of German reparations: “You have the weapons and the force but we have the spirit . . .” used his force against those who inherited the spirit.
You condemned them, these young – and older – Jews who are the cream of Israel. You, who broke with the majority in the years before the state and who was condemned as a “poresh,” a dissident who refused to accept the rule of the majority, now cloak yourself in the mantle of the majority. You, who once understood that there are things greater than mere peace, now wrap yourself in a tallit shekula techelet, the classical Hebrew garment of hypocricy, and thunder that you will not allow anyone to “impede” the peace. You, who cries “peace, peace” and knows that there is no peace, but who lacks the courage to confess the enormity of your epic mistake drives blindly forward, and takes our people to a terrible future that G-d alone can calculate.
I saw the tears and the broken hearts of Jews who felt that which you lost- the pain over the abandonment of an inch of the Land of Israel. I saw the agony of women who wept and the fear on the faces of the small children your soldiers dragged away. I saw the bulldozers and the cranes and the terrible, awful destruction of a city in Israel. I saw the murder of Yamit and know the king who gave the order. And I know that some day the rabbis will ask “Why is it that Menachem, who had such a past, was not destined to rule for long? Because he diminished a city in Israel.”
No, Menachem, I do not seek your thanks. That which I did was not done for you but because I love the young people who so much love their land. You have brought on us tragedy. Concerning Abraham our father, who signed a treaty of peace with the Philistines and thus gave over to them rule in a part of Eretz Yisrael, our Rabbis say. The Holy One, Blessed Be He, said [in anger]: ‘ You gave him seven sheep [as a symbol of the treaty] because of this his children will destroy seven of your tabernacles: the Tabernacle of the Congregation, Gilgal, Nov, Givon, Shilo, and both Holy Temples… “” (Breishit Rabbah 54).
Menachem, the All Mighty will not forgive us for out contempt for the Land of Israel. I weep for the tragedy you have brought on your people. May G-d help us all, for I remember the words that the young people had painted on the bunker wall. “Truth is heavy and that is why there are so few who carry it
May 14, 1982